I think I find myself in good company on this particular post in advocating for the "marketplace of ideas" as the most persuasive branch of reasoning for staunch protection of the first amendment. Though, in my opinion, the marketplace of ideas and autonomy feel very intertwined. If the idea of the autonomy branch is that free speech is essential for the development of the person and, in turn, society at large, then the marketplace of ideas essentially feels like the end point of autonomy where once people themselves are developed in their ideas, they participate in the marketplace of ideas and hence we get prevailing societal dialogues. I do think that each of these branches are undeniably affected by the completely unlevel economic playing field and the existence of algorithms that capitalize on our existing ideas and beliefs to monetize engagement. Because of this, I don't think that any of these branches can really exist as they've been theorized. I don't doubt that they are manifested to a degree in every day life, but I do doubt any belief that we exist in an actual "marketplace of ideas" or that the speech many of us engage in or with is necessarily getting us closer and closer to "truth." Nor do I believe that, especially under this administration, we are able to achieve autonomy as individuals through (in part or in full) first amendment protections. I believe that we are stifled especially in our autonomy by past and present limits on the first amendment.
Like many others, I found myself most interested in the difference between the "marketplace of ideas" ideology and the feasibility of such an idea when up against genuine human behaviors. I tend to believe in the marketplace of rights as an idea. I think that having many opinions available in an uncensored manner is very important. I am on Mill's side, that in a perfect world, people would view all sides of an issue before being able to determine the true answer (the truth). Because of that, naturally a marketplace of ideas would be essential. However, I don't find that it ends up being utilized as it should. The article discusses a modern version of this theory that is designed to combat the more 21st-century obstacles to "the truth". I think that the concept has problems that extend beyond the modern constraints that we're seeing now. Obviously, there are the issues related to the popularity of "echo chambers" and the misuse of information, both online and in the media. I think that these types of issues have threatened the concept of the marketplace for as long as it has existed. Journalistic hoaxes have occurred since the country was new. There have always been people who stick to "their own" and don't branch out or accept new opinions, some even going so far as to disregard modern medicine. I don't disagree that the new technology at our fingertips may make it simpler to cloud the marketplace of ideas, but I believe the issues have always been there, and we are quick to blame it on our recent developments instead of understanding that humans as a rule can be stubborn. Many people just have an inherent disregard of what we could refer to as "the other stalls" in the marketplace.
It’s a fascinating point! Perhaps the marketplace of ideas has always been more aspiration than reality—but maybe the aspiration itself is still a useful guide.
I understand why the oldest theory of free speech is to help us find the truth and that at the time that John Milton and John Stuart Mill were thinking about free speech this seemed like the most prominent reason for it. However, I think that the marketplace of idea concept is not realistic or attainable today as this open debate idea because of the use of social media and honestly human nature in general. In both our online presence and our physical presence in the world, everyone selects who they want to listen to, talk to, follow, or even watch. Although it may seem easier online because these algorithms are programmed to prioritize what individuals like or gravitate towards opposed to what they don't. However, the same can be said for an individual walking down the street, sitting in a busy public setting or even listening to the radio or news.
I also think this idea isn’t attainable even if social media and technology were not so prevalent in our lives. Unless an individual is living in or working in an area that has some diversity this idea that so many different views and opinions will be prevalent, let alone discussed, seems unrealistic. As well people tend to gravitate towards others who have similar interests, ideas and morals so I’m skeptical that this melting pot of opinions and thoughts will meet the same complexity that was thought of when this marketplace of ideas concept came to be. Although distortion is and always will be prevalent, I think it ultimately comes back to the individual on how open they are to seeing/hearing other views and also be skeptical on what they see or hear to be true.
You're right. I'd add, though, that while the theory doesn’t guarantee exposure to every viewpoint, it assumes we can seek them out if we choose to. The challenge now is that while access has expanded more than ever, our habits and algorithms often make it harder to actually exercise that choice.
In recent years, I have found myself less and less convinced by this "marketplace of ideas" theory and I find it strange that some people are obsessed/fixated on this notion that there was ever a time in American history that people just randomly congregated in public settings with the goal of transacting ideas. And I find it even more strange, given the lack of a historical precedent for this idea, the people who believe in "the public square" or "the marketplace of ideas" also often believe that people nowadays are entitled something that never truly existed in the first place. Travel to any major American city and you will inevitably find someone on some street corner shouting into a megaphone about how some group of people is going to burn in Hell or how some major catastrophe was actually orchestrated by a malevolent group of the world's wealthiest. This is, in essence, the last/only vestige of the "public square" that some people are so obsessed with resurrecting. And when you see this person shouting conspiracies on the street corner, you will also notice that every single passerby does exactly that: pass by. They walk right past the person without ever acknowledging their existence, let alone stopping to engage a thoughtful, nuanced discussion with the person. Because that's exactly what you do when a stranger is doing that. If you were to go back in time to the Nation's founding, I imagine that the situation would play out similarly. People have jobs, families, and other obligations to attend to. On a practical level, it is silly to think that someone is going to spend their already-limited free time to stop and artfully discuss politics, religion, philosophy, etc with a complete stranger on a street corner. This version of "the marketplace of ideas" has never existed. People more often engage in fruitful political discussions among friends/family in informal settings not viewable to the public, and that still occurs to this day.
With that in mind, I think of free speech as being an important vehicle for self-expression, and government restriction on speech should be scrutinized because of the theory of distrust. I am ambivalent about the self-government theory, mainly due to how easy and fast misinformation circulates nowadays.
Yes, the “marketplace of ideas” was never really a historical fact, but more of an idealized story about how speech should work in a democracy. In practice, people never gathered in public squares to debate truth; they’ve mostly talked within their own circles. I like how your comment calls out that disconnect between myth and reality.
You’re also right that misinformation today makes the “marketplace” idea even harder to believe in. Free speech as self-expression and as a safeguard against government abuse is a more realistic and still very strong justification. And it raises an interesting question: how far can those values carry the First Amendment in an age of misinformation — can they do the same democratic work the marketplace was supposed to do?
As I was reading this portion of the reading on Tuesday, I had just finished a TikTok of Jake Tapper talking about how all major news networks have refused to sign the Pentagon's new restrictions on the press. Not only does it remind me of the licensing of printing press, but this restriction reminds me of exactly why we need the First Amendment in the first place.
First, in the context of truth - If the Pentagon media rule actually sticks, there will be no way for me to trust what is coming out of the press room. When the publication requires approval and can only discuss certain topics, it makes me wonder what they're hiding. I'm obviously not asking for our nation's deepest national security secrets, but I think there is a level of transparency required coming from the Pentagon. When we're only getting one pre-approved side of the story, and there is no way for people to develop their own ideas and come to the truth.
Second, in the context of self-government - If a major arm of our government is silencing the press and only allowing certain information out, how can anyone come to a conclusion on the state of the country or if the military's actions are justified and ethical? We should be able to get this information (within the bounds of what is unclassified) to make informed decisions and shape our views for upcoming elections.
What's most concerning to me is that the news outlets that don't sign will have their press passes taken away. If this actually happens, the channel of communication will effectively shut down and Pete Hegseth and OAN will become our only source (and I don't necessarily trust their "fair and unbiased" view). It's alarming to me that this hasn't gotten more widespread criticism because it seems to be a clear attack on the First Amendment.
You make a strong case, and I think you’re right to see the danger in restricting press access. The legal picture is a little more complicated, though. The key constitutional question isn’t simply whether this “feels” like censorship, but whether the Pentagon’s rules are genuinely about protecting national security or whether they’re being used to suppress scrutiny. Courts give the executive broad deference in classifying military information, but if the restrictions cross into viewpoint discrimination (limiting coverage to control criticism), that would trigger serious First Amendment problems.
Legally, there’s an important difference between prior restraints (which are almost always unconstitutional) and conditions on access (which are often upheld). The government doesn’t have to grant every outlet a press pass, as long as the rules are content-neutral and tied to legitimate security needs. The danger, as you note, is if “neutrality” becomes a cover for managing the narrative. In that sense, this situation tests the boundary between secrecy and censorship. It’s always a balancing act between protecting national security and preserving the public’s right to hold power accountable.
The marketplace of ideas theory of free speech is not incredibly convincing to me because just as competition in markets may help discover better prices, it also creates the opportunity for people to take advantage like with monopolies. As mentioned in the article, i think algorithms, ad money and misinformation can distort what people see and hear. I think for a marketplace of ideas to function for the benefit of society it must also provide better conditions for truth-seeking including independent media sources, transparency about funding and authorship, and providing tools to verify the information. I believe that free speech is important right for a society, however, I think it can easily become corrupted.
I think it is important for citizens to be able to engage in public discourse. Yet, I agree with scholars Sunstein and Fiss that a democracy requires structural fixes to ensure the discussion is fair such as disclosure rules for political campaigns, public interest media, spending limits. Posts concerns are valid as what is first seen as a responsible regulation is easily turned into a government bias or censorship.
But, I think there is a lack of consideration of the harm that comes from racist or prejudiced rhetoric that positions itself to be factual or scientific such as all Muslims are terrorists by using mistranslations of Islamic scripture or any harmful stereotyping toward an entire racial, ethnic or religious group. The harm that resulted from this type of speech about muslims on news networks resulted in public support for the War on Terror that has killed and displaced millions of people and wasted trillions in U.S. taxpayer money. To me, that is a larger harm, and worth being protected.
I think autonomy and distrust of government are also interesting theories of free speech. I thought that distrust's purpose was the most convincing to me as government's have shown throughout history that they cannot be trusted fully to decide which speech is too dangerous. However, I think the line is more easily drawn than these theorists would like to admit. There are many things that require discourse, but the character of entire groups of people is not one of those.
I am a very firm believer in the marketplace of ideas rationale. The cases we have covered throughout the semester have reinforced the belief that the best counter to bad speech is good speech. That belief was stressed heavily in Snyder. I do not think many people would lose sleep if the Westboro Baptist Church members were censored. However, how the 2000s and 2010s played out to me reinforces that the system works as designed. They gained national media attention with these heinous protests and traveled all over the country. I think the counterspeech worked perfectly and as such we almost never hear from this group anymore, and this was accomplished without any censorship required.
We also discussed in class whether this system works efficiently because the overton window constantly shifts. A student mentioned that the majority opinion changing overtime is evident that the best ideas rise to the top and I think that is completely correct. Within my lifetime attitudes regarding LGBT issues have shifted greatly. The process may be slow but the marketplace of ideas theory is the best way to allow this change to occur.
The specific restriction that comes to mind is the restriction of speech on campus in recent years. Without the ability to actually participate in important discourse and debate we are stifled in the development of our autonomy as our authors have described it, and therefore restricted in the marketplace of ideas.
I find myself feeling very strongly about the First Amendment, as I learn more about it in law school, this only strengthens. Before this class however, I thought the “Marketplace of Ideas” theory was the most compelling reason to protect speech. In the last few class discussions I noticed that a lot of my own reasoning roots back to the “Distrust of Government” theory. Ultimately, I believe they all have an important role to play in protecting free speech, but having them each laid out and considered as we continue to learn has been insightful for me.
While I feel the truth of the importance of free speech protections come from a combination of the four theories (as you described at the end of the article), I focus on the personal autonomy aspect not despite it's focus on non-political speech, contrary to Bork, but because of that. One concern I have with the other approaches (mainly truth and self-government) is that they will lead to the government deciding that non-political speech, such as art and literature, can be censored, because it falls outside the marketplace of ideas and the need for self-government. And while I understand the arguments that the marketplace of ideas would apply to artistic speech (and perhaps would be clearer because there is an economic marketplace for this kind of speech), and artistic speech does help people become more rounded as voters, better able to govern themselves, my argument would be that these focus too much on the result of speech rather than the goal of the speaker. One should be free to speak to no audience, speaking or creating for their own personal enjoyment, and if others wish to hear them speak, the government should not be permitted to prevent this (and the government should not assume that people would rather not hear others speak simply because of what the speaker is saying). I also feel that it takes a too limiting view of the Constitution. While the Constitution is a political document, it ultimately contains our values as Americans, and therefore should not be limited to just political speech. It should protect speech more reflective of our cultural values.
While the Marketplace of Ideas was never a "real" thing, I do think it still carries value. Society does not need to interact directly with someone on the corner of a street, shouting about whatever views or ideas they have, for the megaphone-wielder's speech to have some impact on their listeners. Being faced with different, even reprehensible, ideas can be enough to foster new questions about what we believe or why we believe it in the first place. I don't believe society needs to debate the people it disagrees with for their words to register or make some kind of impact, because people can hold an internal dialogue themselves. Algorithms and social media don't really change this for me either, while people can be more at risk of being fed certain beliefs based on their viewing habits, people have always been selective with who they listen to, the medium has just changed.
I think I find myself in good company on this particular post in advocating for the "marketplace of ideas" as the most persuasive branch of reasoning for staunch protection of the first amendment. Though, in my opinion, the marketplace of ideas and autonomy feel very intertwined. If the idea of the autonomy branch is that free speech is essential for the development of the person and, in turn, society at large, then the marketplace of ideas essentially feels like the end point of autonomy where once people themselves are developed in their ideas, they participate in the marketplace of ideas and hence we get prevailing societal dialogues. I do think that each of these branches are undeniably affected by the completely unlevel economic playing field and the existence of algorithms that capitalize on our existing ideas and beliefs to monetize engagement. Because of this, I don't think that any of these branches can really exist as they've been theorized. I don't doubt that they are manifested to a degree in every day life, but I do doubt any belief that we exist in an actual "marketplace of ideas" or that the speech many of us engage in or with is necessarily getting us closer and closer to "truth." Nor do I believe that, especially under this administration, we are able to achieve autonomy as individuals through (in part or in full) first amendment protections. I believe that we are stifled especially in our autonomy by past and present limits on the first amendment.
Which limits on free speech do you feel are stifling our autonomy?
Like many others, I found myself most interested in the difference between the "marketplace of ideas" ideology and the feasibility of such an idea when up against genuine human behaviors. I tend to believe in the marketplace of rights as an idea. I think that having many opinions available in an uncensored manner is very important. I am on Mill's side, that in a perfect world, people would view all sides of an issue before being able to determine the true answer (the truth). Because of that, naturally a marketplace of ideas would be essential. However, I don't find that it ends up being utilized as it should. The article discusses a modern version of this theory that is designed to combat the more 21st-century obstacles to "the truth". I think that the concept has problems that extend beyond the modern constraints that we're seeing now. Obviously, there are the issues related to the popularity of "echo chambers" and the misuse of information, both online and in the media. I think that these types of issues have threatened the concept of the marketplace for as long as it has existed. Journalistic hoaxes have occurred since the country was new. There have always been people who stick to "their own" and don't branch out or accept new opinions, some even going so far as to disregard modern medicine. I don't disagree that the new technology at our fingertips may make it simpler to cloud the marketplace of ideas, but I believe the issues have always been there, and we are quick to blame it on our recent developments instead of understanding that humans as a rule can be stubborn. Many people just have an inherent disregard of what we could refer to as "the other stalls" in the marketplace.
It’s a fascinating point! Perhaps the marketplace of ideas has always been more aspiration than reality—but maybe the aspiration itself is still a useful guide.
I understand why the oldest theory of free speech is to help us find the truth and that at the time that John Milton and John Stuart Mill were thinking about free speech this seemed like the most prominent reason for it. However, I think that the marketplace of idea concept is not realistic or attainable today as this open debate idea because of the use of social media and honestly human nature in general. In both our online presence and our physical presence in the world, everyone selects who they want to listen to, talk to, follow, or even watch. Although it may seem easier online because these algorithms are programmed to prioritize what individuals like or gravitate towards opposed to what they don't. However, the same can be said for an individual walking down the street, sitting in a busy public setting or even listening to the radio or news.
I also think this idea isn’t attainable even if social media and technology were not so prevalent in our lives. Unless an individual is living in or working in an area that has some diversity this idea that so many different views and opinions will be prevalent, let alone discussed, seems unrealistic. As well people tend to gravitate towards others who have similar interests, ideas and morals so I’m skeptical that this melting pot of opinions and thoughts will meet the same complexity that was thought of when this marketplace of ideas concept came to be. Although distortion is and always will be prevalent, I think it ultimately comes back to the individual on how open they are to seeing/hearing other views and also be skeptical on what they see or hear to be true.
You're right. I'd add, though, that while the theory doesn’t guarantee exposure to every viewpoint, it assumes we can seek them out if we choose to. The challenge now is that while access has expanded more than ever, our habits and algorithms often make it harder to actually exercise that choice.
In recent years, I have found myself less and less convinced by this "marketplace of ideas" theory and I find it strange that some people are obsessed/fixated on this notion that there was ever a time in American history that people just randomly congregated in public settings with the goal of transacting ideas. And I find it even more strange, given the lack of a historical precedent for this idea, the people who believe in "the public square" or "the marketplace of ideas" also often believe that people nowadays are entitled something that never truly existed in the first place. Travel to any major American city and you will inevitably find someone on some street corner shouting into a megaphone about how some group of people is going to burn in Hell or how some major catastrophe was actually orchestrated by a malevolent group of the world's wealthiest. This is, in essence, the last/only vestige of the "public square" that some people are so obsessed with resurrecting. And when you see this person shouting conspiracies on the street corner, you will also notice that every single passerby does exactly that: pass by. They walk right past the person without ever acknowledging their existence, let alone stopping to engage a thoughtful, nuanced discussion with the person. Because that's exactly what you do when a stranger is doing that. If you were to go back in time to the Nation's founding, I imagine that the situation would play out similarly. People have jobs, families, and other obligations to attend to. On a practical level, it is silly to think that someone is going to spend their already-limited free time to stop and artfully discuss politics, religion, philosophy, etc with a complete stranger on a street corner. This version of "the marketplace of ideas" has never existed. People more often engage in fruitful political discussions among friends/family in informal settings not viewable to the public, and that still occurs to this day.
With that in mind, I think of free speech as being an important vehicle for self-expression, and government restriction on speech should be scrutinized because of the theory of distrust. I am ambivalent about the self-government theory, mainly due to how easy and fast misinformation circulates nowadays.
Yes, the “marketplace of ideas” was never really a historical fact, but more of an idealized story about how speech should work in a democracy. In practice, people never gathered in public squares to debate truth; they’ve mostly talked within their own circles. I like how your comment calls out that disconnect between myth and reality.
You’re also right that misinformation today makes the “marketplace” idea even harder to believe in. Free speech as self-expression and as a safeguard against government abuse is a more realistic and still very strong justification. And it raises an interesting question: how far can those values carry the First Amendment in an age of misinformation — can they do the same democratic work the marketplace was supposed to do?
As I was reading this portion of the reading on Tuesday, I had just finished a TikTok of Jake Tapper talking about how all major news networks have refused to sign the Pentagon's new restrictions on the press. Not only does it remind me of the licensing of printing press, but this restriction reminds me of exactly why we need the First Amendment in the first place.
First, in the context of truth - If the Pentagon media rule actually sticks, there will be no way for me to trust what is coming out of the press room. When the publication requires approval and can only discuss certain topics, it makes me wonder what they're hiding. I'm obviously not asking for our nation's deepest national security secrets, but I think there is a level of transparency required coming from the Pentagon. When we're only getting one pre-approved side of the story, and there is no way for people to develop their own ideas and come to the truth.
Second, in the context of self-government - If a major arm of our government is silencing the press and only allowing certain information out, how can anyone come to a conclusion on the state of the country or if the military's actions are justified and ethical? We should be able to get this information (within the bounds of what is unclassified) to make informed decisions and shape our views for upcoming elections.
What's most concerning to me is that the news outlets that don't sign will have their press passes taken away. If this actually happens, the channel of communication will effectively shut down and Pete Hegseth and OAN will become our only source (and I don't necessarily trust their "fair and unbiased" view). It's alarming to me that this hasn't gotten more widespread criticism because it seems to be a clear attack on the First Amendment.
You make a strong case, and I think you’re right to see the danger in restricting press access. The legal picture is a little more complicated, though. The key constitutional question isn’t simply whether this “feels” like censorship, but whether the Pentagon’s rules are genuinely about protecting national security or whether they’re being used to suppress scrutiny. Courts give the executive broad deference in classifying military information, but if the restrictions cross into viewpoint discrimination (limiting coverage to control criticism), that would trigger serious First Amendment problems.
Legally, there’s an important difference between prior restraints (which are almost always unconstitutional) and conditions on access (which are often upheld). The government doesn’t have to grant every outlet a press pass, as long as the rules are content-neutral and tied to legitimate security needs. The danger, as you note, is if “neutrality” becomes a cover for managing the narrative. In that sense, this situation tests the boundary between secrecy and censorship. It’s always a balancing act between protecting national security and preserving the public’s right to hold power accountable.
The marketplace of ideas theory of free speech is not incredibly convincing to me because just as competition in markets may help discover better prices, it also creates the opportunity for people to take advantage like with monopolies. As mentioned in the article, i think algorithms, ad money and misinformation can distort what people see and hear. I think for a marketplace of ideas to function for the benefit of society it must also provide better conditions for truth-seeking including independent media sources, transparency about funding and authorship, and providing tools to verify the information. I believe that free speech is important right for a society, however, I think it can easily become corrupted.
I think it is important for citizens to be able to engage in public discourse. Yet, I agree with scholars Sunstein and Fiss that a democracy requires structural fixes to ensure the discussion is fair such as disclosure rules for political campaigns, public interest media, spending limits. Posts concerns are valid as what is first seen as a responsible regulation is easily turned into a government bias or censorship.
But, I think there is a lack of consideration of the harm that comes from racist or prejudiced rhetoric that positions itself to be factual or scientific such as all Muslims are terrorists by using mistranslations of Islamic scripture or any harmful stereotyping toward an entire racial, ethnic or religious group. The harm that resulted from this type of speech about muslims on news networks resulted in public support for the War on Terror that has killed and displaced millions of people and wasted trillions in U.S. taxpayer money. To me, that is a larger harm, and worth being protected.
I think autonomy and distrust of government are also interesting theories of free speech. I thought that distrust's purpose was the most convincing to me as government's have shown throughout history that they cannot be trusted fully to decide which speech is too dangerous. However, I think the line is more easily drawn than these theorists would like to admit. There are many things that require discourse, but the character of entire groups of people is not one of those.
I am a very firm believer in the marketplace of ideas rationale. The cases we have covered throughout the semester have reinforced the belief that the best counter to bad speech is good speech. That belief was stressed heavily in Snyder. I do not think many people would lose sleep if the Westboro Baptist Church members were censored. However, how the 2000s and 2010s played out to me reinforces that the system works as designed. They gained national media attention with these heinous protests and traveled all over the country. I think the counterspeech worked perfectly and as such we almost never hear from this group anymore, and this was accomplished without any censorship required.
We also discussed in class whether this system works efficiently because the overton window constantly shifts. A student mentioned that the majority opinion changing overtime is evident that the best ideas rise to the top and I think that is completely correct. Within my lifetime attitudes regarding LGBT issues have shifted greatly. The process may be slow but the marketplace of ideas theory is the best way to allow this change to occur.
The specific restriction that comes to mind is the restriction of speech on campus in recent years. Without the ability to actually participate in important discourse and debate we are stifled in the development of our autonomy as our authors have described it, and therefore restricted in the marketplace of ideas.
I find myself feeling very strongly about the First Amendment, as I learn more about it in law school, this only strengthens. Before this class however, I thought the “Marketplace of Ideas” theory was the most compelling reason to protect speech. In the last few class discussions I noticed that a lot of my own reasoning roots back to the “Distrust of Government” theory. Ultimately, I believe they all have an important role to play in protecting free speech, but having them each laid out and considered as we continue to learn has been insightful for me.
While I feel the truth of the importance of free speech protections come from a combination of the four theories (as you described at the end of the article), I focus on the personal autonomy aspect not despite it's focus on non-political speech, contrary to Bork, but because of that. One concern I have with the other approaches (mainly truth and self-government) is that they will lead to the government deciding that non-political speech, such as art and literature, can be censored, because it falls outside the marketplace of ideas and the need for self-government. And while I understand the arguments that the marketplace of ideas would apply to artistic speech (and perhaps would be clearer because there is an economic marketplace for this kind of speech), and artistic speech does help people become more rounded as voters, better able to govern themselves, my argument would be that these focus too much on the result of speech rather than the goal of the speaker. One should be free to speak to no audience, speaking or creating for their own personal enjoyment, and if others wish to hear them speak, the government should not be permitted to prevent this (and the government should not assume that people would rather not hear others speak simply because of what the speaker is saying). I also feel that it takes a too limiting view of the Constitution. While the Constitution is a political document, it ultimately contains our values as Americans, and therefore should not be limited to just political speech. It should protect speech more reflective of our cultural values.
While the Marketplace of Ideas was never a "real" thing, I do think it still carries value. Society does not need to interact directly with someone on the corner of a street, shouting about whatever views or ideas they have, for the megaphone-wielder's speech to have some impact on their listeners. Being faced with different, even reprehensible, ideas can be enough to foster new questions about what we believe or why we believe it in the first place. I don't believe society needs to debate the people it disagrees with for their words to register or make some kind of impact, because people can hold an internal dialogue themselves. Algorithms and social media don't really change this for me either, while people can be more at risk of being fed certain beliefs based on their viewing habits, people have always been selective with who they listen to, the medium has just changed.