Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marwa A's avatar

Brandenburg was very interesting. I think the test that developed out of it is helpful. The article points out how in Hess the court found that Hess's words were too vague and future oriented to constitute an imminent threat and that his statement expressed defiance instead of incitement of violence. I like that the Brandenburg test allows room for heated, provocative, and reckless rhetoric to be protected as that type of rhetoric is essential to the right to protest.

It is just hard for me to reason that the KKK was allowed to broadcast themselves on TV carrying guns and talking about revengence on the government. But that is more about the what the purpose of the group is more than anything else. I can however acknowledge through looking at how the rule was applied in Hess does make it clearer to me the importance of this type of rule. I liked the last paragraph of the article, especially the part where it says free societies can draw strength from enduring passion, not suppressing it.

Abby F's avatar

Reading Brandenberg served as a test of my own biases, and while I ultimately believe the Brandenburg decision was correct, I want to be mad about it if only because the guy was a KKK leader. That being said, I do agree that we need room for heated, ugly rhetoric, or demonstrators would get locked up for their passionate hyperboles regularly.

The term “later” in Hess really was the Courts whole schtick; obviously an action is not imminent if you are scheduling your mayhem for a later time. I feel like it was huge for the Court give merit to the context in this case because protests (and the words that come with them) tend to be fueled by emotion, not the desire to pencil in some casual rioting, and a lot of that emotion comes from people's actual lived experience with oppression. The distinction between dissent and disloyalty here is going to stick with me, because dissent is not disloyalty. It is passion for change.

Allowing hateful, negative, and just plain bad speech to be protected is far less dangerous than letting the government decide which expressions/emotions are too ‘threatening’ to allow. This serves as a good reminder for me to work on my own patience and remember that (reluctantly) tolerating certain speech, is not the same as agreeing with it.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?