Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marwa A's avatar

The executive order is clearly a violation of the First Amendment and the ruling in Johnson. I don't really understand the purpose of this executive order, as the article implies, reverence cannot be legislated back into public life. I do not think burning the flag on its own counts as imminent lawless action or as fighting words. The administration's actions concerning the First Amendment are very upsetting as we saw many student activists recently targeted. These are the exact situations the First Amendment is meant to protect against.

Abdullah Mahmood's avatar

A lot of the thread is circling the conduct versus speech line, and rereading Johnson I don't think the Court really decided it there. It just took the conduct as expressive enough to get into the First Amendment and went straight to Texas's two interests. The breach of the peace one dropped out because no disturbance actually occurred or threatened to occur. The nationhood interest is what actually did the work, and the Court said those concerns "blossom only when a person's treatment of the flag communicates some message," which put the case "outside of O'Brien's test altogether." That feels like the part that matters for the order. The order's whole move is to point prosecutors at other laws, but under Johnson it isn't really about which law gets used, it's whether the interest behind the enforcement depends on the message. If it does, O'Brien drops out the same way it did for Texas.

15 more comments...

Ready for more?