Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Marwa A's avatar

I agreed with Mackinnon's take that when court's treat all speech as equal, they overlook speech that silences others. The law should take subordination through speech more seriously as she argues. Pornography is a great example of this; where people in positions of power engage in speech that is dehumanizing to an entire group of people. I think pornography, and other speech that dehumanizes entire groups of people crosses the boundary between making us uncomfortable to having deep effects on society. I am not sure what the exact answer is to regulate social messaging that teaches inequality, but I think the statute in American Booksellers was a great start as it focused directly on regulating the harm that resulted from pornography and not the viewpoint that is being expressed by it.

Miah Tompkins's avatar

I agree with Mackinnon that pornography shapes people's views of women and especially perpetuates negative views of them and behavior toward them. There is tons of scientific research delving into this. I also think that the porn industry is extremely harmful to many of the women who are apart of it. In my ideal world pornography (such as on a pornography website) would probably be banned. However, in reality, I don't think there is a way to do that without also censoring valuable forms of speech that overlap with it. Additionally, I keep thinking of what Strossen said in the hate speech panel. I think her sentiment about enforcement applies here too. Most likely, censorship of pornography would end up unfairly targeting those it is designed to protect because those in charge of enforcing the censorship often don't have minorities best interests in mind.

12 more comments...

Ready for more?