Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lucas Smith's avatar

As much distaste as I have for judicial balancing, I do think it may be the best method we have for fairly adjudicating individual rights when they come in conflict with legitimate government interests. In my opinion, the position that a categorical approach reflects a "crystallized" balancing, is accurate. While I'd give due credit to the need for foreseeability and predictability to maintain a rule of law, I nonetheless think that an individualized assessment of the competing interests at stake in each case would allow the Court to evolve with the times -as the truth seeking function of freedom of speech operates to gradually erode the erroneous premises on which older decisions may have rested.

Ellie Saur's avatar

I appreciate the article's distinction between the discretion of economic liberty and the heightened scrutiny placed on freedom of speech. I think the gap derives from the inherent strength of unambiguous versus ambiguous founding language. While one demands a liberty, the other proscribes future liberties associated with due process. The ambiguous language often makes it difficult to find and define the right, but does it water-down the applied protection itself?

It makes me wonder if still today we inherently value rights that were explicitly protected in the Bill of Rights more than substantive due process rights that were derived out of the malleable word "liberty" through judicial review. In this way, it makes it easy to see how a categorical approach's protection can be so strong. It isn't up to a weighing inquiry and therefore a subjective review. Americans operate in their everyday life knowing there is a freedom of speech. There is value in the general public understanding and therefore accessing this "golden shield" so readily.

31 more comments...

Ready for more?